Twilight Lexicon Discussion Forums

I haven't finished it yet, I've been skipping around.

Biggest surprise so far was Victoria's backstory. The fact she was the oldest member of James's coven. The fact that Heidi used to be in her coven. Her and Laurent's info fill in so much of what was happening behind the scenes in New Moon. I was hoping this would come out. Also the timing of the newborns is explained, why there were some created shortly after James's demise and then there was an explosion of them at the beginning of Eclipse.

It is eerie how many gaps in the background I noticed reading the books, and then how the Guide ended up filling all of those gaps and then some. Bravo, SM!

And I was absolutely wrong on one important point. I though killing Laurent meant he had never communicated with Victoria after he arrived in Forks, but he actually had given her a call and told her that the Cullens were gone. The only thing he couldn't provide was whether or not Bella had left with them, so he was going to investigate further.

The only thing still unknown is why he was in the meadow. I think he must have been following an old scent, but that wasn't brought up in the backstory. Oh well, just about everything else was.

corona wrote:The only thing still unknown is why he was in the meadow. I think he must have been following an old scent, but that wasn't brought up in the backstory. Oh well, just about everything else was.

I suppose there could be a few reasons. Following an old scent, just passing through, maybe he was making his way up to the baseball field (I don't know if they're near each other). It'd be interesting to find out.

suzzeeQ wrote:My mom's name is in the book. There's one letter difference, but it surprised me when I saw it.

Wow, that's so strange. How weird would it have been if it was spelled the same?!

A lot of things surprised me. I'm sure which one was the biggest. Victoria's backstory and her past with Heidi. I'm surprised we got the names of Nahuel's siblings. The fact that Collin is Jacob's cousin. I'm not sure if it was common knowledge before the guide, but it was surprising (and sweet) to learn that Edward's first kill during his 'rebel days' was Esme's old husband.

Two things surprised me.
1. Esme and Carlisle had met before when he fixed her broken arm.

2. Harry Clearwater had the heart attack when Leah phased in front of him.

One thing that sticks out to me is the odd coincidences. Like the hybrid named Jennifer. She's from Ohio, as am I, I'm friends with a Twilight fan fic beta named Jennifer, and I have a character in some of my fan fics that I'm writing named Jennifer who was born in Ohio.

Just odd coincidences.

Until now, my biggest surprise was who kill Esme's husband... I always assumed that was one of the reason why Rosalie say that she have a better record than Esme... :/

Marie Masen wrote:Two things surprised me.
1. Esme and Carlisle had met before when he fixed her broken arm.

2. Harry Clearwater had the heart attack when Leah phased in front of him.

I was really hoping that it hadn't been Leah phasing that triggered Harry's heart attack. It's a really common plot point in fanfiction (not that that's a problem per say), and I've always thought it was really sad. Hasn't the poor girl been through enough?! So I was hoping that it didn't have anything to do with her phasing.

Kate wrote:Until now, my biggest surprise was who kill Esme's husband... I always assumed that was one of the reason why Rosalie say that she have a better record than Esme... :/

Ooooh, I'd never thought of that. I don't see Esme as the revenge type, but then again I don't really see her as a human drinker type either. It would be interesting to know just what her record is. I can't exactly imagine Esme being a feral newborn!

Jeakat wrote:

Kate wrote:Until now, my biggest surprise was who kill Esme's husband... I always assumed that was one of the reason why Rosalie say that she have a better record than Esme... :/

Ooooh, I'd never thought of that. I don't see Esme as the revenge type, but then again I don't really see her as a human drinker type either. It would be interesting to know just what her record is. I can't exactly imagine Esme being a feral newborn!

I have difficulty to image Esme killing anybody too, so, I think, wrongly, that maybe if she had cross the path of her first husban...

It seem that I was wrong!

I, too, was a little surprised, intrigued by, and LOVED that Edward took care of Esme's husband. I had sorta always assumed that Esme would have done that (a la Rosalie's reference in Eclipse), but it makes sense that it wouldn't have been her and that Rosalie's reference had more to do with Esme having the normal troubles of a newborn. Esme was, after all, head over heels in love with Carlisle and was probably too distracted between him and her thirst to go after her husband. Another thought with Esme is that she was changed just 2 days after giving birth to her son. No wonder she was always the mothering, compassionate vampire. Talk about all that mothering instinct getting concentrated during vampirization.

And, I like so much how it was Edward who gave Esme justice (even if it was vigilante justice). Can you imagine what he SAW in Esme's head of all that had been done to her and that she probably never talked about? Edward's naturally so protective of everyone he loves. It makes great sense that it was him.

I, too, was also intrigued by Victoria's backstory---well, maybe horrified is a better word. It actually softened me toward her, I think...a little...I mean, she wanted to kill Bella so that's never okay, but no wonder she was so upset. Talk about a terrible upbringing!! And, she was rather duped to believe that James loved her and was finally giving her the stability she'd never had. Just another reminder not to anger the vengeful vampires.