Although a very nice setup for a sequel, this is a valid point. Do you think the screenwriter and director overlooked the fact that Edward should have been able to hear her? Or is Edward's mindreading abilities something they purposefully left out? (Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't remember his mindreading being told about in the movie, or Alice having visions for that matter.)mrshawk wrote:Just wondering why at the end of the movie when Bella and Edward are at the prom, he can't sense that Victoria is so close? The rage in her mind must be very loud and shouldn't Alice have seen her there? Anyone think that's weird?
Movie Inconsistencies?
Moderator: bac
Forum rules
Click for Forum Rules
Click for Forum Rules
-
- Human History Archivist
- Posts: 703
- Joined: Thu Aug 14, 2008 8:15 pm
- Location: Driving through the Tennessee mountains with Emmett
Movie Inconsistencies?
This is the place to discuss anything in the movie you feel is inconsistant with the Twilight universe as we know it from the books.
![Image](http://media.twilightlexicon.com/avatars/BHG/BHGdonebanner.jpg)
Banner by urcoolcarrie
-
- Banging Out Dents with Tyler
- Posts: 311
- Joined: Mon Dec 29, 2008 12:53 pm
- Location: Wandering outside Forks looking for a certain house...
- Contact:
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
Edward actually does mention it, during the restaurant scene, he says "I can read every mind in this room, apart from yours..." And later in the movie, when Bella is in teh hotel with Jazz and Alice, she has a vision of a "room full of mirrors"
So those are mentioned, which makes Edward not noticing Victoria that much more impossible *sigh* Oh well
So those are mentioned, which makes Edward not noticing Victoria that much more impossible *sigh* Oh well
-
- Settled in Forks
- Posts: 21
- Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2009 3:00 pm
- Location: PNW, a semi-short drive to Forks.
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
Yeah, thats a really good point. Edward should have been able to hear her thoughts.
What about the fact that Victoria went to the school and got Bella's address in AZ. Is that how it happened in the book? (Guess its time to re-read it! haha I can't remember the little things) But anyway, I thought they chased her out of Forks. I feel that if she went back into town to go to the school then, they would have known it since they where keeping such an eye out for her! I could be way off, but it seemed a little odd.![Smile :)](./images/smilies/smile.gif)
What about the fact that Victoria went to the school and got Bella's address in AZ. Is that how it happened in the book? (Guess its time to re-read it! haha I can't remember the little things) But anyway, I thought they chased her out of Forks. I feel that if she went back into town to go to the school then, they would have known it since they where keeping such an eye out for her! I could be way off, but it seemed a little odd.
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/smile.gif)
![Image](http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b152/kasskass313/c366f16549408e95be3592668d5f.jpg)
the color Edwards car would be if Alice picked it out
-
- Human History Archivist
- Posts: 703
- Joined: Thu Aug 14, 2008 8:15 pm
- Location: Driving through the Tennessee mountains with Emmett
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
You're right, I remember now that you mention them. It's been too long since I've seen the movie.TeamEdward1918 wrote:Edward actually does mention it, during the restaurant scene, he says "I can read every mind in this room, apart from yours..." And later in the movie, when Bella is in teh hotel with Jazz and Alice, she has a vision of a "room full of mirrors"
Yes, that's the way it happened in the book. Victoria was back in town and Rosalie and Esme were following her. I think Edward tells Bella all this in a phone call while she is in AZ.shinyredvolvo wrote:What about the fact that Victoria went to the school and got Bella's address in AZ. Is that how it happened in the book? (Guess its time to re-read it! haha I can't remember the little things) But anyway, I thought they chased her out of Forks. I feel that if she went back into town to go to the school then, they would have known it since they where keeping such an eye out for her! I could be way off, but it seemed a little odd.
![Image](http://media.twilightlexicon.com/avatars/BHG/BHGdonebanner.jpg)
Banner by urcoolcarrie
-
- Joining the Hunt for Enemies
- Posts: 6978
- Joined: Wed Aug 20, 2008 8:10 pm
- Location: preparing for next winter
- Contact:
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
My biggest pet peeve about the inconsistancies: Emmett was eating!! And I think Rosalie was too, but I'll have to wait for the DVD to come out to know for sure. But that really bugged me.
![Image](http://i497.photobucket.com/albums/rr337/debussygirl/twilight/Edward-Cullen-Banner-twilight-serie.jpg)
Team Edward&Esme~SBS Assistant 2 the Cobosses~APPC
St Cullens Head of Neurology~Tetrarch
Need something to read? Try http://www.jennacooper.com
-
- Changing People's Minds With Jasper
- Posts: 2620
- Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2008 9:02 am
- Location: Singapore
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
Oh yes, I seemed to remember that. I think Edward was eating something at the scene when they sat down at their table in the cafeteria.debussygirl wrote:My biggest pet peeve about the inconsistancies: Emmett was eating!! And I think Rosalie was too, but I'll have to wait for the DVD to come out to know for sure. But that really bugged me.
![Image](http://i420.photobucket.com/albums/pp282/cassis_rose/new%20moon%20888-Scrapblog/newmoon888-8-2.jpg)
Team Carlisle ~ Cullenist - Hail to Carlisle
-
- Running with Leah 'cause she thinks I'm hawt
- Posts: 4633
- Joined: Fri Dec 12, 2008 2:46 pm
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
No- he was picking at his food, but I don't think we ever see Edward putting anything in his mouth.
-
- Has Caught Sight of Edward
- Posts: 1054
- Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 4:33 pm
- Location: The Blue Room
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
I suppose I can't talk about everything that they left out, because not only is it obvious - but it's totally normal when you have a book-to-movie. Yet I really would have liked to see a little more flirtation from Bella when she was walking with Jake. To make it seem more like a relationship was developing, for one - and also to show how badly Bella wanted the info from Jake, and how hard it was for him to give it to her.
And YES - Victoria being at prom bugged me SO much. I really think they could have just showed her skulking through the woods to give off the same impression that she was planning on getting revenge.
Another thing that bugged me was how easy it was for Bella to get away from Alice and Jasper. They completely would have seen her walking by them in the lobby and getting into a cab.
When Renee delivers the line "he never leaves" when Bella is in the hospital asking about Edward...she just says it as if she's reassuring Bella. In the book, it is way more interesting, because Renee is marveling over the fact that this boy seems to be in love with her daughter, and wondering about the intensity. It's when we first get to see how intuitive Renee is.
And YES - Victoria being at prom bugged me SO much. I really think they could have just showed her skulking through the woods to give off the same impression that she was planning on getting revenge.
Another thing that bugged me was how easy it was for Bella to get away from Alice and Jasper. They completely would have seen her walking by them in the lobby and getting into a cab.
When Renee delivers the line "he never leaves" when Bella is in the hospital asking about Edward...she just says it as if she's reassuring Bella. In the book, it is way more interesting, because Renee is marveling over the fact that this boy seems to be in love with her daughter, and wondering about the intensity. It's when we first get to see how intuitive Renee is.
-
- Buying a Better Raincoat
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Mon Dec 01, 2008 1:27 pm
- Location: nowhere interesting, michigan
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
ok so edward probably just wanted to focus on bella and he has mentioned that he can try and block out other people. also hes also mentioned in nm that when he first met victoria he focused so much on what james was thinking that he didnt even pay attention to her. proving he can block stuff out.Bronze Haired Girl wrote:This is the place to discuss anything in the movie you feel is inconsistant with the Twilight universe as we know it from the books.
Although a very nice setup for a sequel, this is a valid point. Do you think the screenwriter and director overlooked the fact that Edward should have been able to hear her? Or is Edward's mindreading abilities something they purposefully left out? (Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't remember his mindreading being told about in the movie, or Alice having visions for that matter.)mrshawk wrote:Just wondering why at the end of the movie when Bella and Edward are at the prom, he can't sense that Victoria is so close? The rage in her mind must be very loud and shouldn't Alice have seen her there? Anyone think that's weird?
and with alice not seeing it..she doesnt see everything especially no one was in danger.
however, i also find it annoying she was there.
![Image](http://i301.photobucket.com/albums/nn47/love_you1_photo/Jackson%20Rathbone/2u77eqp.gif)
![Image](http://i222.photobucket.com/albums/dd52/Amber-Nicole_2010/twilightalicebaseball.gif)
Team Alice & Jasper
-
- Running with Leah 'cause she thinks I'm hawt
- Posts: 4633
- Joined: Fri Dec 12, 2008 2:46 pm
Re: Movie Inconsistencies?
It's going to be difficult to block out someone thinking something like "that girl should die."
Not to mention he would have smelled her.![Smile :)](./images/smilies/smile.gif)
Not to mention he would have smelled her.
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/smile.gif)